Are Giants classified as Beasts or Beings?How did Hagrid know about the Time-Turners?For which subject do the...
If all harmonics are generated by plucking, how does a guitar string produce a pure frequency sound?
What is Crew Dragon approaching in this picture?
What happens if a wizard reaches level 20 but has no 3rd-level spells that they can use with the Signature Spells feature?
What is the meaning of "pick up" in this sentence?
Do any poskim exempt 13-20-year-olds from Mussaf?
How to acknowledge an embarrassing job interview, now that I work directly with the interviewer?
Finding the number of integers that are a square and a cube at the same time
Word to be used for "standing with your toes pointing out"
Quenching swords in dragon blood; why?
What's the rationale behind the objections to these measures against human trafficking?
How would an AI self awareness kill switch work?
How do I add a variable to this curl command?
How do we edit a novel that's written by several people?
Connecting top and bottom of adjacent circles
Called into a meeting and told we are being made redundant (laid off) and "not to share outside". Can I tell my partner?
Why is this code uniquely decodable?
Wanted: 5.25 floppy to usb adapter
When does coming up with an idea constitute sufficient contribution for authorship?
Dilemma of explaining to interviewer that he is the reason for declining second interview
Why does the DC-9-80 have this cusp in its fuselage?
How to prepare vegetables for a sandwich that can last for several days in a fridge?
Do commercial flights continue with an engine out?
Predict mars robot position
Eww, those bytes are gross
Are Giants classified as Beasts or Beings?
How did Hagrid know about the Time-Turners?For which subject do the first years in Hogwarts need “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them”?Where will the second Fantastic Beasts film be set?Are there any significant plot elements in Fantastic Beasts that will be missed if I haven't seen the Harry Potter films?Grindelwald was arrested at the end of Fantastic Beasts, so when did Dumbledore fight him?Who owns the Elder Wand in “Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them”?How many beasts?Why is the in-universe publisher of “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” called Obscurus Books?Why didn't Merope Gaunt turn into an Obscurus?When did Dumbledore write the foreword for the Fantastic Beasts reprint?
In the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them textbook, we learn that wizards classify creatures as either "beasts" or "beings", where beings are usually defined by intelligence level:
Not until 1811 were definitions found that most of the magical community found acceptable. Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.” Troll representatives were questioned in the absence of goblins and judged not to understand anything that was being said to them; they were therefore classified as “beasts” despite their two-legged gait; merpeople were invited through translators to become “beings” for the first time; fairies, pixies, and gnomes, despite their humanoid appearance, were placed firmly in the “beast” category.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
And we see that trolls, for instance, are classified as beasts despite some rudimentary language skills:
The troll is a fearsome creature up to twelve feet tall and weighing over a tonne. Notable for its equally prodigious strength and stupidity, the troll is often violent and unpredictable. Trolls originated in Scandinavia but these days they may be found in Britain, Ireland, and other areas of northern Europe. Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: "Troll"
And "crudeness" is also a factor in being/beast classification:
Several highly intelligent creatures are classified as “beasts” because they are incapable of overcoming their own brutal natures. Acromantulas and Manticores are capable of intelligent speech but will attempt to devour any human that goes near them. The sphinx talks only in puzzles and riddles, and is violent when given the wrong answer.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
However, I don't see giants mentioned anywhere in the book, implying that they're perhaps classified as beings. (We even see centaurs and merpeople in the book, since they're classified as beasts by their own request.)
But trolls and giants... seem rather similar. We can see from Grawp that they're pretty violent and crude, even if they can understand / speak some rudimentary English:
“Anyway, Grawpy,” shouted Hagrid, looking up apprehensively in case of further falling eggs, “I’ve brought some friends ter meet yeh. Remember, I told yeh I might? Remember, when I said I might have ter go on a little trip an’ leave them ter look after yeh fer a bit? Remember that, Grawpy?”
But Grawp merely gave another low roar; it was hard to say whether he was listening to Hagrid or whether he even recognized the sounds Hagrid was making as speech. He had now seized the top of the pine tree and was pulling it toward him, evidently for the simple pleasure of seeing how far it would spring back when he let go.
“Now, Grawpy, don’ do that!” shouted Hagrid. “Tha’s how you ended up pullin’ up the others —”
Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix, chapter 30: "Grawp"
Given this, I'd be rather surprised if giants weren't classified as beasts... but I can't find any mention of them in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.
Do we know if Giants are classified as beasts or beings?
harry-potter
add a comment |
In the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them textbook, we learn that wizards classify creatures as either "beasts" or "beings", where beings are usually defined by intelligence level:
Not until 1811 were definitions found that most of the magical community found acceptable. Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.” Troll representatives were questioned in the absence of goblins and judged not to understand anything that was being said to them; they were therefore classified as “beasts” despite their two-legged gait; merpeople were invited through translators to become “beings” for the first time; fairies, pixies, and gnomes, despite their humanoid appearance, were placed firmly in the “beast” category.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
And we see that trolls, for instance, are classified as beasts despite some rudimentary language skills:
The troll is a fearsome creature up to twelve feet tall and weighing over a tonne. Notable for its equally prodigious strength and stupidity, the troll is often violent and unpredictable. Trolls originated in Scandinavia but these days they may be found in Britain, Ireland, and other areas of northern Europe. Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: "Troll"
And "crudeness" is also a factor in being/beast classification:
Several highly intelligent creatures are classified as “beasts” because they are incapable of overcoming their own brutal natures. Acromantulas and Manticores are capable of intelligent speech but will attempt to devour any human that goes near them. The sphinx talks only in puzzles and riddles, and is violent when given the wrong answer.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
However, I don't see giants mentioned anywhere in the book, implying that they're perhaps classified as beings. (We even see centaurs and merpeople in the book, since they're classified as beasts by their own request.)
But trolls and giants... seem rather similar. We can see from Grawp that they're pretty violent and crude, even if they can understand / speak some rudimentary English:
“Anyway, Grawpy,” shouted Hagrid, looking up apprehensively in case of further falling eggs, “I’ve brought some friends ter meet yeh. Remember, I told yeh I might? Remember, when I said I might have ter go on a little trip an’ leave them ter look after yeh fer a bit? Remember that, Grawpy?”
But Grawp merely gave another low roar; it was hard to say whether he was listening to Hagrid or whether he even recognized the sounds Hagrid was making as speech. He had now seized the top of the pine tree and was pulling it toward him, evidently for the simple pleasure of seeing how far it would spring back when he let go.
“Now, Grawpy, don’ do that!” shouted Hagrid. “Tha’s how you ended up pullin’ up the others —”
Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix, chapter 30: "Grawp"
Given this, I'd be rather surprised if giants weren't classified as beasts... but I can't find any mention of them in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.
Do we know if Giants are classified as beasts or beings?
harry-potter
3
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago
add a comment |
In the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them textbook, we learn that wizards classify creatures as either "beasts" or "beings", where beings are usually defined by intelligence level:
Not until 1811 were definitions found that most of the magical community found acceptable. Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.” Troll representatives were questioned in the absence of goblins and judged not to understand anything that was being said to them; they were therefore classified as “beasts” despite their two-legged gait; merpeople were invited through translators to become “beings” for the first time; fairies, pixies, and gnomes, despite their humanoid appearance, were placed firmly in the “beast” category.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
And we see that trolls, for instance, are classified as beasts despite some rudimentary language skills:
The troll is a fearsome creature up to twelve feet tall and weighing over a tonne. Notable for its equally prodigious strength and stupidity, the troll is often violent and unpredictable. Trolls originated in Scandinavia but these days they may be found in Britain, Ireland, and other areas of northern Europe. Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: "Troll"
And "crudeness" is also a factor in being/beast classification:
Several highly intelligent creatures are classified as “beasts” because they are incapable of overcoming their own brutal natures. Acromantulas and Manticores are capable of intelligent speech but will attempt to devour any human that goes near them. The sphinx talks only in puzzles and riddles, and is violent when given the wrong answer.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
However, I don't see giants mentioned anywhere in the book, implying that they're perhaps classified as beings. (We even see centaurs and merpeople in the book, since they're classified as beasts by their own request.)
But trolls and giants... seem rather similar. We can see from Grawp that they're pretty violent and crude, even if they can understand / speak some rudimentary English:
“Anyway, Grawpy,” shouted Hagrid, looking up apprehensively in case of further falling eggs, “I’ve brought some friends ter meet yeh. Remember, I told yeh I might? Remember, when I said I might have ter go on a little trip an’ leave them ter look after yeh fer a bit? Remember that, Grawpy?”
But Grawp merely gave another low roar; it was hard to say whether he was listening to Hagrid or whether he even recognized the sounds Hagrid was making as speech. He had now seized the top of the pine tree and was pulling it toward him, evidently for the simple pleasure of seeing how far it would spring back when he let go.
“Now, Grawpy, don’ do that!” shouted Hagrid. “Tha’s how you ended up pullin’ up the others —”
Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix, chapter 30: "Grawp"
Given this, I'd be rather surprised if giants weren't classified as beasts... but I can't find any mention of them in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.
Do we know if Giants are classified as beasts or beings?
harry-potter
In the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them textbook, we learn that wizards classify creatures as either "beasts" or "beings", where beings are usually defined by intelligence level:
Not until 1811 were definitions found that most of the magical community found acceptable. Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.” Troll representatives were questioned in the absence of goblins and judged not to understand anything that was being said to them; they were therefore classified as “beasts” despite their two-legged gait; merpeople were invited through translators to become “beings” for the first time; fairies, pixies, and gnomes, despite their humanoid appearance, were placed firmly in the “beast” category.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
And we see that trolls, for instance, are classified as beasts despite some rudimentary language skills:
The troll is a fearsome creature up to twelve feet tall and weighing over a tonne. Notable for its equally prodigious strength and stupidity, the troll is often violent and unpredictable. Trolls originated in Scandinavia but these days they may be found in Britain, Ireland, and other areas of northern Europe. Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: "Troll"
And "crudeness" is also a factor in being/beast classification:
Several highly intelligent creatures are classified as “beasts” because they are incapable of overcoming their own brutal natures. Acromantulas and Manticores are capable of intelligent speech but will attempt to devour any human that goes near them. The sphinx talks only in puzzles and riddles, and is violent when given the wrong answer.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: Introduction
However, I don't see giants mentioned anywhere in the book, implying that they're perhaps classified as beings. (We even see centaurs and merpeople in the book, since they're classified as beasts by their own request.)
But trolls and giants... seem rather similar. We can see from Grawp that they're pretty violent and crude, even if they can understand / speak some rudimentary English:
“Anyway, Grawpy,” shouted Hagrid, looking up apprehensively in case of further falling eggs, “I’ve brought some friends ter meet yeh. Remember, I told yeh I might? Remember, when I said I might have ter go on a little trip an’ leave them ter look after yeh fer a bit? Remember that, Grawpy?”
But Grawp merely gave another low roar; it was hard to say whether he was listening to Hagrid or whether he even recognized the sounds Hagrid was making as speech. He had now seized the top of the pine tree and was pulling it toward him, evidently for the simple pleasure of seeing how far it would spring back when he let go.
“Now, Grawpy, don’ do that!” shouted Hagrid. “Tha’s how you ended up pullin’ up the others —”
Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix, chapter 30: "Grawp"
Given this, I'd be rather surprised if giants weren't classified as beasts... but I can't find any mention of them in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.
Do we know if Giants are classified as beasts or beings?
harry-potter
harry-potter
asked 17 hours ago
MithrandirMithrandir
25.4k9133184
25.4k9133184
3
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago
add a comment |
3
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago
3
3
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
I can't find canon confirmation, but it seems clear that Giants must be Beings.
Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.”
Giants might be among the least intelligent of Beings, but they can certainly speak and communicate effectively with humans. Note that both Dumbledore and Voldemort sent actual envoys to negotiate with the Giants for their support, respecting them as potential allies rather than as dumb beasts to be used.
Also, consider Hagrid. His father apparently actually loved his mother, which would be ... weird (even more than it already is) ... if she was a dumb beast. It seems that she was a person, albeit perhaps a brutish and violent one. Hagrid is certainly a person, and surely not half Beast.
You compare trolls with giants, but the example you use for giants is Grawp, a child by giant standards.
Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Grawp has already got at least that far, and he's not only young (if I recall correctly) but also foreign (he didn't grow up in Britain, and there's no reason to think his mother taught him English - probably he only started learning after meeting Hagrid) and an anomaly among the other giants (being much smaller than average, he's at least physically different, and it's possible he might be mentally disadvantaged as well). If he's already doing as well as the most intelligent/communicative trolls ever recorded, then you do Giants a disservice by placing them on the same level as trolls.
Think of the troll in HP and the Philosopher's Stone, compared with the giants we know of from elsewhere in the series. The troll is just a monster, a beast to be defeated by force and magic - nobody even thinks of trying to reason with it. Grawp is much more intelligent: Hagrid and Hermione can tell him what to do and (sometimes, at least) he'll obey. His and Hagrid's mother was presumably even more intelligent and less brutish, to have been able to catch the eye of a human. And the Giant community led by Golgomath were persuaded to join Voldemort, by way of gifts and common cause, not simply coerced like beasts.
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f206518%2fare-giants-classified-as-beasts-or-beings%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
I can't find canon confirmation, but it seems clear that Giants must be Beings.
Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.”
Giants might be among the least intelligent of Beings, but they can certainly speak and communicate effectively with humans. Note that both Dumbledore and Voldemort sent actual envoys to negotiate with the Giants for their support, respecting them as potential allies rather than as dumb beasts to be used.
Also, consider Hagrid. His father apparently actually loved his mother, which would be ... weird (even more than it already is) ... if she was a dumb beast. It seems that she was a person, albeit perhaps a brutish and violent one. Hagrid is certainly a person, and surely not half Beast.
You compare trolls with giants, but the example you use for giants is Grawp, a child by giant standards.
Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Grawp has already got at least that far, and he's not only young (if I recall correctly) but also foreign (he didn't grow up in Britain, and there's no reason to think his mother taught him English - probably he only started learning after meeting Hagrid) and an anomaly among the other giants (being much smaller than average, he's at least physically different, and it's possible he might be mentally disadvantaged as well). If he's already doing as well as the most intelligent/communicative trolls ever recorded, then you do Giants a disservice by placing them on the same level as trolls.
Think of the troll in HP and the Philosopher's Stone, compared with the giants we know of from elsewhere in the series. The troll is just a monster, a beast to be defeated by force and magic - nobody even thinks of trying to reason with it. Grawp is much more intelligent: Hagrid and Hermione can tell him what to do and (sometimes, at least) he'll obey. His and Hagrid's mother was presumably even more intelligent and less brutish, to have been able to catch the eye of a human. And the Giant community led by Golgomath were persuaded to join Voldemort, by way of gifts and common cause, not simply coerced like beasts.
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
add a comment |
I can't find canon confirmation, but it seems clear that Giants must be Beings.
Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.”
Giants might be among the least intelligent of Beings, but they can certainly speak and communicate effectively with humans. Note that both Dumbledore and Voldemort sent actual envoys to negotiate with the Giants for their support, respecting them as potential allies rather than as dumb beasts to be used.
Also, consider Hagrid. His father apparently actually loved his mother, which would be ... weird (even more than it already is) ... if she was a dumb beast. It seems that she was a person, albeit perhaps a brutish and violent one. Hagrid is certainly a person, and surely not half Beast.
You compare trolls with giants, but the example you use for giants is Grawp, a child by giant standards.
Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Grawp has already got at least that far, and he's not only young (if I recall correctly) but also foreign (he didn't grow up in Britain, and there's no reason to think his mother taught him English - probably he only started learning after meeting Hagrid) and an anomaly among the other giants (being much smaller than average, he's at least physically different, and it's possible he might be mentally disadvantaged as well). If he's already doing as well as the most intelligent/communicative trolls ever recorded, then you do Giants a disservice by placing them on the same level as trolls.
Think of the troll in HP and the Philosopher's Stone, compared with the giants we know of from elsewhere in the series. The troll is just a monster, a beast to be defeated by force and magic - nobody even thinks of trying to reason with it. Grawp is much more intelligent: Hagrid and Hermione can tell him what to do and (sometimes, at least) he'll obey. His and Hagrid's mother was presumably even more intelligent and less brutish, to have been able to catch the eye of a human. And the Giant community led by Golgomath were persuaded to join Voldemort, by way of gifts and common cause, not simply coerced like beasts.
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
add a comment |
I can't find canon confirmation, but it seems clear that Giants must be Beings.
Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.”
Giants might be among the least intelligent of Beings, but they can certainly speak and communicate effectively with humans. Note that both Dumbledore and Voldemort sent actual envoys to negotiate with the Giants for their support, respecting them as potential allies rather than as dumb beasts to be used.
Also, consider Hagrid. His father apparently actually loved his mother, which would be ... weird (even more than it already is) ... if she was a dumb beast. It seems that she was a person, albeit perhaps a brutish and violent one. Hagrid is certainly a person, and surely not half Beast.
You compare trolls with giants, but the example you use for giants is Grawp, a child by giant standards.
Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Grawp has already got at least that far, and he's not only young (if I recall correctly) but also foreign (he didn't grow up in Britain, and there's no reason to think his mother taught him English - probably he only started learning after meeting Hagrid) and an anomaly among the other giants (being much smaller than average, he's at least physically different, and it's possible he might be mentally disadvantaged as well). If he's already doing as well as the most intelligent/communicative trolls ever recorded, then you do Giants a disservice by placing them on the same level as trolls.
Think of the troll in HP and the Philosopher's Stone, compared with the giants we know of from elsewhere in the series. The troll is just a monster, a beast to be defeated by force and magic - nobody even thinks of trying to reason with it. Grawp is much more intelligent: Hagrid and Hermione can tell him what to do and (sometimes, at least) he'll obey. His and Hagrid's mother was presumably even more intelligent and less brutish, to have been able to catch the eye of a human. And the Giant community led by Golgomath were persuaded to join Voldemort, by way of gifts and common cause, not simply coerced like beasts.
I can't find canon confirmation, but it seems clear that Giants must be Beings.
Grogan Stump, the newly appointed Minister for Magic, decreed that a “being” was “any creature that has sufficient intelligence to understand the laws of the magical community and to bear part of the responsibility in shaping those laws.”
Giants might be among the least intelligent of Beings, but they can certainly speak and communicate effectively with humans. Note that both Dumbledore and Voldemort sent actual envoys to negotiate with the Giants for their support, respecting them as potential allies rather than as dumb beasts to be used.
Also, consider Hagrid. His father apparently actually loved his mother, which would be ... weird (even more than it already is) ... if she was a dumb beast. It seems that she was a person, albeit perhaps a brutish and violent one. Hagrid is certainly a person, and surely not half Beast.
You compare trolls with giants, but the example you use for giants is Grawp, a child by giant standards.
Trolls generally converse in grunts that appear to constitute a crude language, though some have been known to understand and even to speak a few simple human words.
Grawp has already got at least that far, and he's not only young (if I recall correctly) but also foreign (he didn't grow up in Britain, and there's no reason to think his mother taught him English - probably he only started learning after meeting Hagrid) and an anomaly among the other giants (being much smaller than average, he's at least physically different, and it's possible he might be mentally disadvantaged as well). If he's already doing as well as the most intelligent/communicative trolls ever recorded, then you do Giants a disservice by placing them on the same level as trolls.
Think of the troll in HP and the Philosopher's Stone, compared with the giants we know of from elsewhere in the series. The troll is just a monster, a beast to be defeated by force and magic - nobody even thinks of trying to reason with it. Grawp is much more intelligent: Hagrid and Hermione can tell him what to do and (sometimes, at least) he'll obey. His and Hagrid's mother was presumably even more intelligent and less brutish, to have been able to catch the eye of a human. And the Giant community led by Golgomath were persuaded to join Voldemort, by way of gifts and common cause, not simply coerced like beasts.
answered 17 hours ago
Rand al'Thor♦Rand al'Thor
97.8k42464650
97.8k42464650
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
add a comment |
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
1
1
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
Even if they satisfy the intelligence, which you make a good point about, what about the "crudeness"? For instance, when Karkus's head gets removed in unpleasant ways. They constantly try to kill each other. Although, I suppose, humans aren't much better about that...
– Mithrandir
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
@Mithrandir Yeah, that doesn't distinguish them too much from certain humans. Werewolves are also classified as beings while in their human form, but Greyback is pretty crude and violent. The key point, perhaps, is that they choose to be that way. A troll or basilisk is like a bear or lion in real life - they're violent and dangerous, but that's just their nature. A giant is like a human murderer - they're intelligent and humanlike enough to know better.
– Rand al'Thor♦
16 hours ago
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f206518%2fare-giants-classified-as-beasts-or-beings%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
3
Are you calling Hagrid half a beast?!
– Rand al'Thor♦
17 hours ago